Black in America

**Marilie** · 07-24-2008, 11:02 AM

Is there already a thread about it? If so please point me in that direction. If you watched it what did you think about it?

**angeladc** · 07-24-2008, 02:00 PM

dad gummit!!! i knew there was something i had missed on yesterday.i didn't get a chance to watch it.

**Warm** · 07-24-2008, 02:26 PM

I was wondering when someone would mention it.

Anyway, this is the clip I caught online last night.

YouTube - CNN's Black In America Clip

**BISHOP** · 07-24-2008, 02:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warm

I was wondering when someone would mention it.

Anyway, this is the clip I caught online last night.

YouTube - CNN's Black In America Clip

Interesting. Wish they had thrown in some 50, 60 &70 year olds in that clip to get an older viewpoint.

**TUCKER** · 07-24-2008, 05:00 PM

I missed it also. But this is not the first one on the subject, so I'm pretty sure whatever they had to say can't be too far removed from what they've said before. Most of these documentaries only have the guts to chat with the outskirts of the Black community. Thats usually enough to satisfy a public that likes to walk on the "outskirts" of the wildside. They don't want to go too deep. From the promos though, I thought this one might be a little different.

**Warm** · 07-24-2008, 07:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TUCKER

I missed it also. But this is not the first one on the subject, so I'm pretty sure whatever they had to say can't be too far removed from what they've said before. Most of these documentaries only have the guts to chat with the outskirts of the Black community. Thats usually enough to satisfy a public that likes to walk on the "outskirts" of the wildside. They don't want to go too deep. From the promos though, I thought this one might be a little different.

Well, watch it tonight at nine on CNN and let us know if you think it's different. *smiles*

**TUCKER** · 07-25-2008, 06:35 AM

missed it again. I was at work.

**sista** · 07-25-2008, 09:56 AM

your more or less on point tucker... trust, you probably didn't miss much...

anyway, here's a critique, if you will:

Quote:

Being black can mean being a suspect

(CNN) -- For Anthony Williams, being black in America means being a suspect.

The 39-year-old former Marine said he's never had any trouble with the law, other than a few traffic violations, and leads a middle-class life in the Atlanta, Georgia, area.

But the AT&T customer care representative said he still gets nervous when he hears that police are looking for a 6-foot-tall black man, "because I know I fit that description."

"I worry I will get pulled over and some police officer decides to shoot first and ask questions later," Williams wrote.

Police recently questioned him in his own driveway after getting complaints that a man was walking in neighbors' yards, Williams said. iReport.com: Tell us what you thought of "Black in America."

"You never know what to expect when you get pulled over by police, and that's how it is when you're black," he said.

Vince Priester of Lithonia, Georgia, said the documentary was "intriguing and moving" and showed that "with all the change we've made as a society, things really haven't changed" for black people.

"You have to tone yourself down when you're around white people," he said. "There's nervousness from white women when I share an elevator with them; they put their hand on their pocketbook."

"You have to almost change yourself, dilute yourself, to live in a white society," he said. iReport.com: Vince Priester describes being black in America

We asked iReport.com writers and readers to share their reaction to part one of the four-hour documentary "Black in America." Dozens of people have responded in the hours since the show ended.

Ayana Gooden, a 34-year-old artist, musician and Web designer in New York, said that she enjoyed the show but that it missed one question: Why?

"To look at how things are in the present, you really have to look at the past," she said.

Slavery and segregation have left deep scars that take generations to heal. She said her own parents couldn't vote without harassment for a third of their lives.

Sonya Freeman of Brooklyn, New York, said the black community is still struggling under white oppression.

"The whole single mom thing and people not being married ... back in the day, especially during slavery time, black people weren't allowed to be married," she said.

She said her grandfather wasn't allowed to go to school past the sixth grade.

"It's not just bad decision-making. It was a whole set of values that were not learned, so they can't be passed down," she said.

Nicole Adams of the Bronx, New York, said that she enjoyed the show but that there were too many issues to cover in just four hours.

"How do you speak about black women and not talk about depression, which is a battle that many women, including myself, face every day?" she asked.

Adams also questioned the emphasis on two-parent families, saying that "the character of the people in the household and not the number was the real determining factor."

The 37-year-old grew up with a mom and a dad but said their relationship was dysfunctional.

"I didn't have a model of a healthy relationship, so I didn't know how to participate productively in a relationship," she said. "I fought so hard not to be like my mom .. that I sabotaged my own relationship."

Being black can mean being a suspect - CNN.com

**TUCKER** · 07-25-2008, 10:36 AM

Thank you sista. This appears to be an excellent synopsis. I find it strange the things that fascinate folks, myself included. Snakes eating, car wrecks, BLACK people, etc. Many are curious, but don't want to get too close, thus programs like this one and others, take you close, but not toooooo close for comfort.

These two ladies seem to get it for certain, I wish it was so clear to so many, many others:

"Ayana Gooden, a 34-year-old artist, musician and Web designer in New York, said that she enjoyed the show but that it missed one question: Why?

"To look at how things are in the present, you really have to look at the past," she said.

Slavery and segregation have left deep scars that take generations to heal. She said her own parents couldn't vote without harassment for a third of their lives.

Sonya Freeman of Brooklyn, New York, said the black community is still struggling under white oppression.

"The whole single mom thing and people not being married ... back in the day, especially during slavery time, black people weren't allowed to be married," she said.

She said her grandfather wasn't allowed to go to school past the sixth grade.

"It's not just bad decision-making. It was a whole set of values that were not learned, so they can't be passed down," she said."

**sista** · 07-26-2008, 01:37 AM

no problem Tuck... those two sista's assessments more or less confirmed for me my decision NOT TO WATCH.... again, why now? and when are we going to see the same treatment of white folx in THEIR AMERIKKKA??

prolly not.... when you're in the power position, everyone else is basically another 'exhibit' in your museum of oppression....

**TUCKER** · 07-26-2008, 05:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sista

when you're in the power position, everyone else is basically another 'exhibit' in your museum of oppression....

EXCELLENT SYNOPSIS!

Watch out now, people gon starting thinking you and I rode in on the same bus!

**sensitiveguy** · 07-28-2008, 09:56 AM

I just watched this yesterday. Overall, I think Soledad did a good job but after a year of preparation I expected more depth. The program hinted at racism in employment, in education, and in the criminal justice system instead of delving deeper...

**Jamal** · 07-28-2008, 12:15 PM

I have to diagree with SG, I thought Soledad did a poor job , her interviewing left a lot to be desired, she is clearly someone who is detached from the Black community. I believe someone like Jaque Reed who is in touch with the Black community would have asked more pertinent questions that would have spoke to the root causes of the problems in the Black community.